Since the challenge is finished why dont you update it? for exemple the shadow in the roots and the foliage in the trees, the smoke and the backgound, this will look really nice! ;) :p

cool work. i like it.  

 *brofist*

Experiencing isometric tiles is something I just a while ago experienced myself as well, how 'bout a brofist?

Adimiravel sua obra.

 Amazing for your first iso :o, very nice :)

 But it looks really nice man

No, not really. I only managed to make the bare elements needed to compose the required scene, but decided to submit it anyway.

 it is not finished is it?

Even if you aren't satisfied, a beginner such as myself may learn a lot from this. Thanks, always a pleasure to see your work.

That's how I feel every time I do pixel art! ^o^ 

I agree that the grass, smoke, trees, and black bg are disappointing.  I like the front side of the building and the water though.

 Well, yeah, I had pretty much no idea what I was doing all the time :D

Nice one, it must have been challenging to do such thing.

[comment redacted due to problem being resolved]

I dont really like the black bg. The leaves and smoke also look like some work is needed. Its a shame today is sunday.

But the building and water are quite nice.

I really like it, but it feels like the grass is a mess... 5/6

Water is overlapping left statue.

Love the grass and water. Tree's folliage looks unfinished compared to the high detail level of the rest of the image and building roof texture is too contrasty for my tastes.